Back to Insights

Thought Leadership

Matthias Tillmann (CEO, FC Schalke 04) and Keal Blache (vivenu) on the Economics of Next-Level Fan Engagement

6 min read
Featured image: Matthias Tillmann (CEO, FC Schalke 04) and Keal Blache (vivenu) on the Economics of Next-Level Fan Engagement

Schalke 04 raised 90 million euros from a bond its own members bought, then held ticket prices flat on promotion to the Bundesliga. The two guests explained why those are the same decision.

The bottom line

  • Tillmann said Schalke carried roughly 170 million euros of debt and more than 100 million euros of negative equity when he arrived in January 2024, with the main sponsor contract expiring and the sleeve partner in bankruptcy.
  • He said the club issued its sixth bond rather than sell equity or the arena, and that fan buyers accept a lower coupon than the market would demand because part of the return is emotional.
  • He said Schalke held regular ticket prices flat on promotion, applying the same margin logic it used to justify holding them flat when the club went down three years ago.
  • Blache argued the decisive variable in ticketing is not distribution but data ownership, because a club that does not own the purchase relationship is leasing the fan rather than keeping them.
  • Tillmann said the US is primarily a talent-access market for Schalke, and the Monterey Bay FC partnership was chosen over an MLS route on player development grounds.

Who was on

  • Matthias Tillmann has been CEO of FC Schalke 04 since 1 January 2024, arriving from trivago, where he sat on the management board through the pandemic. Earlier roles included Vice President Global Markets at Deutsche Bank and a year at RWE Supply and Trading.
  • Keal Blache is VP of Global Partnerships and Strategy at vivenu, the German platform that has run Schalke's ticketing since 2021 and extended that agreement for six more years in March 2025. vivenu was named an Official Ticketing Partner of the United Soccer League in March 2026, a relationship begun in 2024 that now supports close to 70 USL clubs.

The bond priced on membership, not on credit

Tillmann argued the instrument is cheaper than bank debt because the buyer is also the supporter.

  • He said Schalke has issued bonds for many years and consistently paid less than its credit rating alone would imply, because fan buyers price in upside a neutral investor would not.
  • The 2025/30 bond raised 90 million euros against a planned 50 million, split between 75 million from the public offer and 15 million from institutional private placements, at a 6.5% coupon over five years.
  • He said the one-time 1.5% promotion bonus separates it from a conventional bond, because holders participate financially in the outcome they already want.
  • He said the club is 100% member-owned, would only sell equity from a position of strength, and is not considering it.

Price stability is the argument, in both directions

Tillmann said the flat-price decision on promotion follows the same logic the club used when it went down.

  • He said Schalke held prices stable through relegation three years ago because operating and security costs had risen and margins had to hold, so the same reasoning applies now the product has improved.
  • The club confirmed in July 2026 that regular day and season ticket prices stay unchanged for 2026/27, with top-match surcharges returning only for Bayern Munich and Borussia Dortmund.
  • Tillmann said standing tickets in the Nordkurve are capped at 20 euros as policy, and that the 14,000 supporters there produce the atmosphere the rest of the building, hospitality included, is sold on.
  • Blache said price should follow organic supply and demand, that trust breaks when demand is synthetically altered, and that dynamic pricing wins over ten years only where genuine demand exists.

The contested asset is the fan relationship

Blache argued clubs lose commercially when the purchase relationship sits with a marketplace.

  • He said a marketplace communicates with its own interests in mind, so a club that routes fans away is renting the relationship rather than owning it.
  • He tied data ownership directly to sponsorship value, arguing the best partnerships are built on knowing who is in the building and why, which is what produces return for the brand.
  • He said vivenu runs a native secondary market Schalke uses, letting the club set the rules on resale margin and payout.

The US is a talent question first

  • Tillmann framed Schalke's US entry as talent access, citing players with second passports who can move to Europe at 16.
  • The Monterey Bay FC link, announced in February 2026, made Schalke the first Bundesliga club to partner with a USL Championship side, covering scouting and player development.
  • Blache placed that against what USL clubs are building on the data and ticketing side, where owning the fan record is the durable asset.

The takeaway

Schalke's cheapest capital is its own membership and its most valuable commercial asset is the fan relationship, which is why it protects the second while paying for the first.

Free Industry Report

2026 USL Championship Attendance: Down 7.5%

2026 USL Championship Attendance: Down 7.5%

The USL Championship average fell to 5,148 per match while MLS and USL League One grew. We checked every club figure and found venue control, not market size, predicts crowds.

Read the Report