Back to Insights

Club Ownership

Finding a Home for a Pro Club in the U.S.: The Real Playbook Behind Market Entry, Ownership, Stadium Control, and Fan Culture

8 min read
Featured image: Finding a Home for a Pro Club in the U.S.: The Real Playbook Behind Market Entry, Ownership, Stadium Control, and Fan Culture

If you want to understand how professional soccer clubs get built, financed, and scaled in the United States, you cannot start with formations or player recruitment.

You start with four building blocks: market selection, ownership and local credibility, stadium control and revenue rights, and supporter culture and community buy-in.

On a recent One Soccer Nation (OSN) panel discussion, I sat down with a group that has lived this process from multiple angles league expansion, stadium development, club ownership, MLS operations, and supporter culture building: Steven R. Short (formerly Lexington Sporting Club, and previously 13 years at USL leading expansion and club strategy), Mark McCullers (President and Founder, McCullers Group), Doug Erwin (Vice Chairman and Chief Brand Officer, Greenville Triumph SC), Chris Keeney (A3 Sports Consulting and United Sports Property), and Fred Matthes (GM, Annapolis Blues FC, former D.C. United and Sacramento Republic FC executive).

1. How Investors Actually Find Club Opportunities

A lot of people assume there is a single "pipeline" for investing in U.S. soccer. The reality is messier and more human. Sometimes it is a cold inbound from someone who hears a market is heating up. Sometimes it is a network referral from someone already inside the sport. Sometimes it is the league pushing a market and trying to match it with a credible ownership group.

The investor truth: good opportunities cluster around people, not websites. That is why conference lobbies, informal meetings, and trusted relationships keep showing up as the real marketplace.

2. The Greenville Case Study: How a Club Can Start "By Accident," Then Scale on Purpose

Doug explained that Greenville's opportunity basically fell into their lap through local relationships and early league interest in the market. Greenville did not become successful because the market magically "loved soccer." It worked because the league already saw the market as strong, the ownership group had deep local credibility, and the club committed to operating like a real business, not a hobby.

Chris added the detail that matters most to investors: when a respected local family or leadership group backs the project, the market often responds faster because trust is already built.

Operator lesson: you do not just sell tickets, you inherit a reputation. If your ownership group carries trust, you start with a head start.

3. Engaged Local Ownership Is a Cheat Code

There is a direct correlation between engaged local ownership and club success. Because the earliest stage of a club is not about soccer it is about relationships with city leadership, chamber of commerce and business community ties, sponsorship sales and local partnerships, navigating permits, sites, and development politics, and building a real fan base, not just a launch day crowd.

Fred framed it clearly using Sacramento: the builder in that market was not just an investor, he was a connector across business, politics, and community. That connective tissue is what makes the club real.

Investor takeaway: money is required, but legitimacy is the multiplier.

4. Out-of-Market Ownership Can Work, But Absentee Ownership Is the Killer

The panel's view was nuanced: out-of-market ownership can work, minority shares and local partners can fill the gap, and the club must hire strong local leadership. But ownership must still show up and engage periodically, and the front office must have authority and resources to execute.

Steven put it bluntly: absentee ownership is the worst-case scenario.

5. Stadium Control Is Not a Nice-to-Have It Is the Business Model

Mark laid out the stadium reality that every serious investor must understand: private developers are not building lower-division soccer stadiums across the country for one reason most do not pencil without public-private partnership tools. That is why the stadium conversation usually becomes a finance and incentives conversation: tax increment financing, hospitality taxes, development incentives, negotiated operating agreements, and long-term leases that do not crush the club on day one.

Doug added the operator pain point: when you do not control the venue, you lose revenue across concessions, parking, merchandise, broadcast quality, date control, and the ability to host other events.

Investor takeaway: a club without venue control is often a club without margin.

6. The Real Upside of Venue Control Is Not Your 20 Home Dates

Steven made the best framing for investors: a team may have 20 home matches, but a venue can have 200 revenue opportunities. If you control the stadium, you can host tournaments, high school and college events, concerts, rugby, corporate rentals, community events, and sports tourism programming.

Owning or operating the venue turns the club from a ticket business into a year-round asset manager. That is why the Atlanta Braves development model keeps getting referenced across American sports.

Operator takeaway: the club becomes the anchor tenant, but the venue becomes the platform.

7. Soccer Authenticity Matters More Than People Admit

Fred raised a point that every investor should factor into brand building: soccer looks better, feels better, and sells better when it is played in a soccer-specific environment. Football lines, bad sightlines, and baseball conversions hurt viewer experience, broadcast optics, brand perception, sponsor appeal, and supporter culture energy.

This is not just aesthetics. It is product quality. If the goal is long-term growth, the product must look and feel legitimate.

8. Supporters Are Not an Accessory They Are Early-Stage Infrastructure

Chris and Fred both described how supporter groups should be invited into the process early: where they want to sit, how they want to enter, what rituals they want to build, how the club can support without controlling them, and how the club can unify groups that may compete with each other.

One line that stuck: "A house is just a house until a family moves into it and makes it their own." That is the stadium and supporter relationship in one sentence.

Doug also made a practical point: groups like the American Outlaws can be an immediate signal of soccer density in a market and often become an early mobilizing force.

Operator takeaway: supporters are not a marketing tactic, they are a community operating system.

The Real Blueprint for Launching a Pro Club in the U.S.

Validate the market beyond population look for growth curve, civic pride, competition density, and local soccer infrastructure. Build an ownership group that carries local trust. Solve stadium control early, not eventually. Build the club around community engagement, not just game day. And invite supporters into the process you are not building a crowd, you are building culture.

Soccer in the U.S. is entering a phase where infrastructure, real estate strategy, and community alignment will define the winners. The question is not "can this market support soccer?" The question is: can you assemble the ownership, stadium, and culture stack to make the club sustainable?

Listen to the full episode

Free Industry Report

2026 USL Championship Attendance: Down 7.5%

2026 USL Championship Attendance: Down 7.5%

The USL Championship average fell to 5,148 per match while MLS and USL League One grew. We checked every club figure and found venue control, not market size, predicts crowds.

Read the Report